Call US | (609)494-7228 | OPEN Thur, Fri & Sat 10am - 5pm, Sun 10am - 4pm | CLOSED Mon, Tue & Wed

Kind Words From

Happy Clients

“I’ve always found The Haymarket to be magical, with such a wide range of high quality toys for all ages (including grown-ups like me). Really kind and helpful staff as well. Perfect for that special gift.” • Beth M., Ship Bottom

“40 years of fun! The Hays are purveyors of unique toys and games. Stop in when you are on LBI.” • Andrea S.

“The Haymarket has been a place I’ve used for many, many years. They’re above and beyond helpful if you have a problem and will do whatever it takes to correct the issue. I absolutely love this place and will always see them for our hobby needs on LBI.” • Bryan S.

“We visit The Haymarket when we’re lucky enough to vacation on LBI. We love their selection of puzzles, crafts and games for all ages. We also make sure we pick up some Christmas gifts before heading home. So happy The Haymarket is in Ship Bottom.” • Olivia C.

“Have been shopping at this place in Ship Bottom for years, grew up with it. Great hobby store and enough toys to keep young and old happy.” • Chris D.

“I love this toy store! It has a large variety of the best toys and games. It’s also a great stop for anyone that likes model cars, trains, planes or rockets.” • Susan G.

“Absolutely the best toy store on LBI! You can find items you’d never find at a big box store. They have everything from stuffed animals for kids, adult hobby toys and hard-to-find games. I highly recommend the Haymarket! They have everything for the family.” • Nick D.